|
THE RIGHTS OF EMPLOYEES IN
TAKING AND RETURNING FROM MILITARY LEAVE
INTRODUCTION
Newspapers abound with optimistic reports that many service
men and women may soon be returning home from Iraq and
Afghanistan. As these men and women return to civilian life,
employers will face some important issues. Many will seek to
return to their old jobs. Others will want to confirm that
they have been afforded all of the rights they were entitled
to receive while they were away. Employers who mishandle such
issues will face employee complaints, bad press, and possible
liability. To that end, this article provides employers with a
quick overview of the rights afforded to employees on, and
returning from military leave.
The applicable federal law is the Uniformed Services
Employment and Reemployment Rights Act (hereinafter "USERRA";
38 U.S.C. § 4301). The USERRA prohibits discrimination by an
employer against any member of the armed services in hiring,
retention, re-employment, promotion opportunities, or any
benefit of employment by an employer. (38 U.S.C. § 4311(a).) A
person alleging that an employer has violated the USERRA may
commence legal proceedings against the employer either
independently or with the assistance of the Attorney General.
(38 U.S.C. § 4323.) An employee can recover any lost wages or
benefits resulting from an employer’s violation of USERRA.
Further, courts may double the amount as liquidated damages if
it finds that an employer’s violation of USERRA was willful.
Under state law, employee rights in connection with
military leave law are established by the Military and
Veterans Code (hereinafter "M&V Code"). The M&V Code provides
that it is a misdemeanor to discriminate against members of
the military because of their membership in the military. (M&V
Code § 394(f).) Any person that discriminates against a member
of the military is liable for actual damages and reasonable
attorney’s fees incurred by the injured party. Employers
should be prepared to adhere to whichever statute affords its
employees the greatest level of rights.
SALARY
Under federal law, employers do not owe a salary to employees
on active leave. (38 U.S.C § 4316.) However, under California
law, an employer’s obligation to pay an employee’s salary
while on military leave depends upon whether the employee is
called up for active duty (military leave) or training
(temporary military leave). Employees on active duty, who have
been employed for a period of "not less than one year," are
entitled to pay for the first 30 days of military leave. (M&V
Code 395.02.) There is an exception for National Guard
members. A National Guard member on active duty is entitled to
receive his or her salary for the first 30 calendar days
regardless of his or her length of service with the public
employer. (M&V Code 395.05.)
Employees on temporary military leave, with at least one
year of service with the public agency, or at least one year
of combined military/ employment service, are entitled to
receive pay for the first 30-days of temporary military leave.
(M&V Code 395.01.) (There is no exception here for members of
the National Guard.)
VACATION AND SICK LEAVE BENEFITS
Under federal law, if an employee accrues vacation and sick
leave benefits based on seniority, then the employee is
"entitled to the seniority and other rights and benefits
determined by seniority that the person had on the date of the
commencement of service in the uniformed services plus the
additional seniority and rights and benefits that such person
would have attained if the person had remained continuously
employed." (38 U.S.C. § 4316(a) [emphasis added].) However, if
the accrual of vacation and sick leave benefits is not based
on seniority, then the employer must treat the individual
returning from military service as it treats any other
employee who took leave for non- military purposes. (38 U.S.C.
§ 4316(b).) Thus, the employer is not required to provide the
employee with preferential treatment.
Under state law, an employee on military leave for the
purpose of active duty, except as a member of the National
Guard, shall not accrue sick leave or vacation while on such
leave. (M&V Code § 395.1(b).) Employees who are ordered to
active duty as a National Guard member shall accrue vacation
and holiday privileges, but not sick leave, for the first 30
days of active service, regardless of the length of service
with the public employer. (M&V Code § 395.05(a).)
An employee on temporary military leave (training) with at
least one year of service with the public agency, or at least
one year of combined military/ employment service, continues
to accrue the same vacation, sick leave, and holiday
privileges for up to a maximum period of 180 days. (M&V Code §
395(d).) Members of the National Guard on temporary leave must
also have at least one year of service with the employer or
one year of combined military/ employment service in order to
be entitled to the accrual of vacation and sick leave.
HEALTH INSURANCE BENEFITS
An employee who is on military leave for less than 31 days
cannot be required to pay more than the employee’s regular
share, if any, for health coverage. (38 U.S.C. § 4317(a)(2).)
For employees on military leave for longer periods of time,
the employer is not required to provide health insurance
benefits, but must give the employee the option of electing
continuing coverage. An employee can elect to continue
coverage for up to a 24- month period and may not be required
to pay more than 102% of the full premium. (38 U.S.C. § 4317.)
This provision mirrors the employer obligations set forth
under the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of
1986 ('COBRA"). Plan reinstatement must immediately follow
reemployment, and exclusion or waiting periods may not be
applied to employees or family members.
REEMPLOYMENT AFTER MILITARY LEAVE
As a general proposition, an employer is required to reemploy
an employee returning from military leave at the employee’s
request to be reinstated.
Under the USERRA, an employee returning from military
service, for reasons other than war or national emergency,
must seek reinstatement with his/ her employer within a
certain time frame that depends on the length of his/her
military leave. For example, if an employee has taken 1-31
days of military leave, the employee must report to the
employer no later than the beginning of the first regularly
scheduled work period on the first full calendar day following
the completion of the period of service. For a leave of more
than 30 days but less than 180 days, the employee must submit
an application for reemployment with the employer not later
than 14 days after the completion of the period of service.
For a leave of more than 180 days, the employee must submit an
application for reemployment with his/her employer within 90
days of his/ her completion of military service. (38 U.S.C. §
4312(e)(1).)
If the employee does not seek reemployment within the
specified time frame, he/she does not automatically forfeit
his right to reemployment. Rather, the employee "shall be
subject to the conduct rules, established policy, and general
practices of the employer pertaining to explanations and
discipline with respect to absences from scheduled work." (38
U.S.C. § 4312(e)(3).) Thus, employers should review their
policies and practices in anticipation of such issues.
Significantly, federal law does not require an employer to
reemploy an individual returning from military service if 1)
the employer’s circumstances have changed such that
reemployment is impossible or unreasonable, 2) employment
would impose an undue hardship on the employer, or 3) the
position in question only exists for a brief, non-recurrent
period and there was no reasonable expectation that such
employment would continue indefinitely or for a significant
period. (38 U.S.C. § 4312(d)(1).)
California law also provides for reemployment after
military service. Section 395.1 of the M&V Code states that an
employee returning from active duty after serving in time of
war or national emergency is entitled to reinstatement within
6 months after the termination of military service, but not
later than 6 months after the end of the war, emergency, etc.
Under state law, the right to reemployment does not extend to
a public employee who fails to return to his or her position
within 12 months after the first date he or she could
terminate his or her active service. (M&V Code 395.1(b).)
CONCLUSION
In anticipation of increasing numbers of employees returning
from military service, employers should be armed with the
answers to employee questions about their rights while on
military leave. Being prepared to answer these questions will
help employers avoid unnecessary complaints, negative press,
and costly claims. Employers with questions about specific
employees and/or scenarios should seek the advice of legal
counsel. |